(De)centralized Water Futures: Key Dimensions of Infrastructure, Governance, and Operations

Alicia Dailey Cooperman, Elliott School of International Affairs
Jenny Linder Rempel, Energy and Resources Group
Ellis Adjei Adams, University of Notre Dame
Alida Cantor, Portland State University
Manuela Muñoz Fuerte, Texas Tech University
Jeremiah Osborne-Gowey, Texas A&M University
Nicole J. Wilson, University of Manitoba
Cassandra L. Workman, The University of North Carolina at Greensboro
Melissa Beresford, San Jose State University
Leila M. Harris, The University of British Columbia
Linda E. Méndez-Barrientos, University of Denver
Sameer H. Shah, College of the Environment
Amber Wutich, Arizona State University
Justin Stoler, College of Arts and Sciences

Abstract

Water system centralization and decentralization have variously been promoted as key to achieving household water security and Sustainable Development Goal 6.1. We argue that the lack of specificity with which scholars and practitioners use the terms centralization and decentralization limits our understanding of different water system configurations and their impacts. In this Primer, we provide a framework for thinking about levels of (de)centralization across three linked system dimensions: infrastructure, governance, and operations and maintenance. We encourage those analyzing water systems to characterize (de)centralization with respect to these multiple dimensions, as well as the system's broader political-economic and hydro-climatic contexts. Emphasizing the importance of delineating the scale of analysis, we highlight distinct system configurations and the prevalence of hybridity. Increased specificity about dimensions and scale can clarify how the character of, or changes to, a given system impact users, which is critical to assessing their implications for water security, sustainability, and equity. We conclude with recommendations for future research to analyze the opportunities and challenges associated with different water system configurations. This article is categorized under: Human Water > Water Governance.