Publication Date
6-25-2026
Document Type
Article
Publication Title
Journal of the Australian Library and Information Association
DOI
10.1080/24750158.2026.2692786
Abstract
Universities increasingly foreground institutional research (IR) dashboards to steer ‘student success’ agendas, yet much of the library’s contribution operates through relationships that IR cannot readily capture. As a result, the library’s engagement with IR efforts remains underexplored in library and information science scholarship. Drawing on descriptive survey data from 66 academic librarians and library administrators, together with nine semi-structured interviews conducted across the California State University system, this study examines how library resources are allocated at course level and whether IR data inform those decisions. Findings indicate that librarians rely far more on local relationships, timing within the academic calendar and instructors’ requests than on system dashboards. Although instructional collaborations are often effective in supporting student learning, they are difficult to represent in institutional metrics and remain structurally fragile, depending heavily on individual personalities, staffing continuity and supportive leadership. Participants also identified practices associated with more consistent outcomes, particularly internal information sharing and active engagement in university-wide conversations. These findings suggest that partnerships should be stewarded as networks rather than treated as a series of one-off liaison activities. This study therefore reframes the contribution libraries provide as relational, human-centred and context-sensitive, and argues for university structures that recognise and sustain this qualitative work alongside traditional quantitative analytics.
Keywords
Academic libraries, asset-based approaches, information literacy, institutional research data, librarian-instructor collaboration, student success
Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 4.0 License.
Department
Information
Recommended Citation
Rebecca Bryant Penrose, Geoff Walton, Kirsty Fife, and Mary K. Bolin. "From Deficit to Dialogue: Reassessing the Role of Institutional Data in Library Resource Deployment" Journal of the Australian Library and Information Association (2026). https://doi.org/10.1080/24750158.2026.2692786