Description
For cost-efficiency, public safety, and sustainability, improving long-term performance in highway projects is imperative for public administrations. Project delivery and procurement methods provide an opportunity to align design and construction processes with this goal. While previous studies have explored whether project delivery methods impact the long-term performance of highway projects, these studies did not focus on how core elements within project procurement relate to long-term performance. Thus, to fill this gap, this research explores how and to what extent long-term evaluation criteria are considered in design-build best-value procurement of highway projects. To this end, the team conducted content analysis on 100 projects procured between 2009 and 2019 by 19 DOTs across the U.S. The analysis of 365 evaluation criteria found that (1) roughly 11% of them related to long-term performance. (2) The weight given to these criteria in the overall technical proposal was lower than 30%. (3) Sixty-five percent (65%) of long-term evaluation criteria focused on design while 15% related to materials and technology, respectively. The results of this study are a stepping stone to initiate a deep exploration of the relationship between procurement practices and actual project performance. Currently, as sustainability and life cycle assessments remain top concerns in infrastructure projects, this line of research may benefit DOTs and highway agencies across the U.S. and worldwide.
Publication Date
7-2022
Publication Type
Report
Topic
Miscellaneous, Planning and Policy, Sustainable Transportation and Land Use
Digital Object Identifier
10.31979/mti.2022.2130
MTI Project
2130
Mineta Transportation Institute URL
https://transweb.sjsu.edu/research/2130-Highway-Maintenance-Evaluation
Keywords
Highway maintenance, Project delivery, Design-Build, Procurement, Evaluation and assessment
Disciplines
Construction Engineering and Management | Infrastructure | Structural Engineering | Transportation | Transportation Engineering
Recommended Citation
Maria Calahorra-Jimenez. "Contracting Strategies: A Different Approach to Address Long-term Performance" Mineta Transportation Institute Publications (2022). https://doi.org/10.31979/mti.2022.2130
Research Brief
Included in
Construction Engineering and Management Commons, Infrastructure Commons, Structural Engineering Commons, Transportation Commons, Transportation Engineering Commons
